[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

Re: Theos-World Re: Betty Bland's Statement Regarding Recent Election

Jul 30, 2009 06:56 PM
by MKR

In this day of Internet, elected General Secretaries of National Sections
hold important and prestigious positions in TS. Normally members highly
regard and trust them. So anything they say or put in writing is expected to
be truthful and backed up with verifiable facts.  When I saw Betty Blandâs
statement in a quaint website that âAlthough no one is contesting the
outcome of the 2008 presidential election, the problem remains that the
machinations of the international elections are unsound.â, I was surprised.

In order that I understand the precise meaning and implication, I looked up
the term âmachinationsâ. Dictionary defined it as:

+a scheming or crafty action or artful design intended to accomplish some
usually evil end+

Having made the statement, is it unreasonable for dues paying members to
explain in simple terms what Betty meant when she made the statement. I
wrote to Betty on June 3 inquiring a response. To this day, there is no

When a theosophical leader heading the second largest TS section, makes such
statements, keeping silent only affects the opinion members have in their
leader and in turn reflects on TS. Since the motto of TS is There is no
religion higher than Truth, it also negatively affects the TS.

I hope we will hear from Betty soon. I do not know how continued silence
helps her or TSA.



On Thu, Jul 30, 2009 at 6:31 PM, jasonsriram <> wrote:

> MK
> Maybe it is just a case of "see it happened before". However, I agree with
> your assessment that there was no case of claims of either electioneering or
> false or misleading statements from either party as I recall in 1980. In
> fact I was in Adyar in 1980 and have no recollection of rancour or ongoing
> spatting as is occurring now.
> In 1976 she (Rukmini) was nominated to be President of India, a post she
> declined. I spoke with her in 1981 about it and she stated she declined
> because she had "no interest in political life". So I really doubt that it
> was anything other that an unwanted result from a post she felt she was
> qualified for.
> If Betty can disclose more on the source of her information I would be very
> interested to know more on this.
> Jason
> --- In <>, MKR
> <mkr777@...> wrote:
> >
> > Six weeks ago, Betty Bland, President (National Secretary) of TS in
> America,
> > in a cyberspace write-up stated:
> > .
> > +++
> > Although no one is contesting the outcome of the 2008 presidential
> election,
> > the problem remains that the machinations of the international elections
> are
> > unsound. For example, the international presidential contest in 1980,
> when
> > Radha Burnier won over Rukmini Devi, was also fraught with differences of
> > opinion.
> > +++
> > .
> > The comments coming from the National Head of TS in America, is
> surprising
> > and need elaboration so that members can clearly understand the
> statement.
> > .
> > Dictionary defines machinations as:
> > .
> > ** a scheming or crafty action or artful design intended to accomplish
> some
> > usually evil end
> > .
> > When anyone holding a high position in a spiritual organization such as
> TS
> > makes such statements, I think members are owed an explanation backing up
> > the statement.
> > .
> > The second comment about the 1980 election, is even more interesting. I
> have
> > never seen any allegation from Rukmini Devi or her supporters inside TS
> or
> > outside TS about anything questionable about the 1980 election.
> > RukminiDevi, whose husband George
> > Arundale was President succeeding Annie Besant, is very widely known in
> > India and around the world due to her long active involvement in TS and
> her
> > other outside activities. If there was any problem whatsoever with the
> 1980
> > election, we would have heard them loud and clear soon after the
> election. I
> > have not heard of any allegation or complaint. I do not know what
> > information Betty Bland is privy to that ordinary members around the
> world
> > are ignorant of. When such public statements are made, it is not
> > unreasonable for members ask for substantiation.
> > .
> > Several weeks ago, I wrote an open letter to Betty requesting
> clarification.
> > We have not heard anything so far.
> > .
> > The above situation does not help anyone. Already, level of trust many
> > members have in the TS leaders is very low. This was the result of the
> > election campaign and post election ultra secret attempt by general
> council
> > members to disenfranchise members world-wide and seize the power to
> appoint
> > the president.
> > .
> > I hope soon we will get some response substantiating the above
> statements.
> > Due to the nature of the statements, by keeping silent, the questions
> > surrounding the statements, are not going to go away.
> > .
> > MKR
> > .
> > Visit
> >
> >
> > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
> >

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

[Back to Top]

Theosophy World: Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application