[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

Possible positions regarding HPB and the WT project

May 12, 2009 07:55 AM
by Govert Schuller

Dear Daniel,

Thanks again for the links. 

There are a few ways to reconcile HPB and the WT project:

1) If you start with HPB as the true standard, than you can deduce from her writings that AB, CWL and K were all mistaken and either perpetrating a fraud, or subject to self-deception, or deception by meta-emperical entities like dugpas, or possibly even by the Masters themselves (vide Nigel's hypothesis).

2) If you start with the idea that most transcendental events connected to the WT project were genuine, than you can conclude that not all of HPB's ideas are necesarrily helpful to understand what really happened. Some do, some don't. And she might be mistaken. You just have to weigh her statements about Maitreya with the statements made by CWL, K, Hodson, Scott and Anrias, all of whom were witnessing one way or the other of Maitreya's involvement in the WT project.

3) HPB's ideas are right and the WT project was genuine at the same time. There was just some unfortunate mix-up in names and concepts. Therefore no reason to become an anti-Krishnamurti, fundamentalist Blavatskyite nor an anti-Theosophical fundamentalist Krishnamurtiite. 

As I made clear before, you start with 1) and I start with 2) and that has to do with the particular history of our spiritual quest and the decisive formative spiritual events while on our way. 

So my repost to you would be:

Regardless of what HPB wrote and taught, it looks to me that something very profound, mysterious and transformational happened with the WT project and some august high spiritual intelligences were involved and their names might well have been Koot Hoomi, Maitreya, Buddha and Sanat Kumara. 

In the end I think we'll just have to agree to disagree and hopefully agreeably so. 


  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: danielhcaldwell 
  Sent: Tuesday, May 12, 2009 12:03 AM
  Subject: Theos-World What did HPB teach about Maitreya & the Torch-Bearer??

  Regardless of what various Theosophical writers after HPB have written
  about the coming Maitreya and the Torch-Bearer of Truth of the 20th century, what did H.P. Blavatsky originally write and teach about each of these subjects?

  I give again links to postings that collate the relevant HPB material. These pages give what HPB taught regardless of what other individuals later WANTED to make of the teachings.

  H.P. Blavatsky on the true Maitreya

  Was Alice Bailey "the New Torch-Bearer of Truth"?

  Also relevant to these 2 topics is what HPB said elsewhere about
  the Christ and the Messiah craze:

  ". . . true Theosophists will never accept ...a Christ made Flesh...

  H.P. Blavatsky on Christ -- the true esoteric SAVIOR

  'Lo here! and lo there!': The Messiah Craze

  And finally the following relevant postings should be kept in mind as one goes over the above material:

  Dr. Santucci on Besant & Leadbeater's teachings.....

  Was Besant /Leadbeater disseminating "a misleading Mayavic ideation?

  Annie Besant on Her Messiah: Was this Part of the Messiah Craze?

  Annie Besant Under DELUDING Influences

  Did Besant & Leadbeater follow the advice in the 1900 KH Letter?

  I'm planning to put all of this material on our website so it can be easily found by students and researchers.



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]


[Back to Top]

Theosophy World: Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application