[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

Re: Fw: Theos-World J Krishnamurti Videos on Youtube

May 07, 2009 07:06 PM
by Cass Silva

I imagine the reason why Krishnamurtians join groups is the same
reason Theosophists join groups - to discuss the philosophy behind
it.  K said that the only way to truth is to follow your own path -
which means look at yourself and your lower ego and discover who
you are, what drives you have, what ideals you have, what motivates
you.  This in itself is a life long experiment - no point in searching for
higher self when lower self is contaminated.  If we all clean up this
contamination in our lower self there will be the ending of wars and
man's inhumanity to man.


From: Anand <>
Sent: Friday, 8 May, 2009 3:25:12 AM
Subject: Re: Fw: Theos-World J Krishnamurti Videos on Youtube

Topic related to Truth raises many questions, in the context of Krishnamurti' s teaching.
In the Star Bulletin August 1931, Page 7 - J. Krishnamurti says:
" So I have made it prefectly clear that what is generally believed by the
Christian, the Theosophist, the Hindu, the Buddhist to be Truth, has nothing in
common with what I say"

Now, if Krishnamurti' s Truth is different from Truth of above mentioned religions, then what is Truth according to him? I have not read anywhere Krishnamurti describing what Truth is according to him.
JK says 'you find Truth yourself'. What are people supposed to find when JK did not say what Truth is according to him? And suppose they find some kind of Truth, how will people know that that is the Truth JK was talking about?

Another thing I find strange about followers of J. Krishnamurti is this. These followers praise Krishnamurti' s teaching. Krishnamurti asked people not to follow any teacher, not to read books on religions/spiritual ity etc, not to join spiritual organizations. According to JK these things corrupt minds of people and they exploit followers. I often find that JK's followers praise Krishnamurti' s teaching and then join other spiritual organizations, read books on spirituality, have Gurus and are aspiring for discipleship. 
If followers of JK think that JK's teaching is right, then why do they do exactly opposite of what JK taught? And if they do exactly opposite of what JK taught, then why do they praise JK's teaching?
Take the example of Katinka. She has been promoting JK's teaching for many years. And yet she reads many books, she not only joins organizations, but now inviting suggestions about how to make TS organization better. She aspire for discipleship as mentioned in Theosophy. So, when followers of JK praise his teaching and at the same time do exactly opposite of what JK taught, it makes me wonder. Another thing it suggest me is that these followers still read books on spirituality, join organizations and have Gurus because they are not satisfied with J.Krishnamurti' s teaching and what his teaching gives them.
Anand Gholap

      Enjoy a better web experience. Upgrade to the new Internet Explorer 8 optimised for Yahoo!7. Get it now.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

[Back to Top]

Theosophy World: Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application