[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

Do I need to correct my views or does Anand need......

Mar 02, 2009 07:45 AM
by danielhcaldwell

Do I need to correct my views or does Anand need to
correct his views???

On Feb. 28, 2009, Anand said I need to correct my views:

I think you need to correct your views.
First of all you are ASSUMING that so called Mahatma Letters were
written by Mahatmas. I wrote on this subject earlier and explained why
these letters are NOT AS AUTHENTIC as believed.
We know most Mahatma Letters were materialized by Blavatsky, according
to her own admission. And we also know that contents of the letter
depended on chela's own development.
That means you CAN NOT take statements from Mahatma Letters to support
Blavatsky or her teaching [or Anand's own statement made below in 
2005???], as letters were materialized by herself.
If you do, it will be like saying "Blavatsky was right because she
said she was right"
caps added.

Now compare this statement with what Anand Gholap wrote on Theos-Talk 
on Feb 12, 2005 about these Mahatma Letters:

Most people believe that Master K.H. sent one letter to C.W. 
Leadbeater. ACTUALLY HE SENT more letters to Leadbeater. 
Here second letter is given which was received [THROUGH H.P. 
BLAVATSKY] on the night of the same day as first letter was 
received. ...This letter IS IMPORTANT for two reasons. First is it is 
CONFIRMATION that Leadbeater was accepted as disciple and second 
reason is it should remind members that in communications due respect 
should be given to Mr. Leadbeater which disciple deserves from 
ordinary people. Here is that letter taken from Letters from the 
Masters of the Wisdom - First Series
To C. W. Leadbeater

Since your intuition led you in the right direction and made you 
understand that it was my desire you should go to Adyar immediately, 
I may say more. The sooner you go to Adyar the better. Do not lose 
one day more than you can help. Sail on the 5th, if possible. Join 
Upasika at Alexandria. Let no one know that you are going, and may 
the blessing of our Lord and my poor blessing shield you from every 
evil in your new life.

Greeting to you, my new chela.


Show my notes to no one.
caps added


[Back to Top]

Theosophy World: Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application