Some Examples of the Changes in The Voice of the Silence
Feb 09, 2006 11:14 PM
"Why are there hundreds of changes in this Theosophy Company's
edition of HPB's THE VOICE OF THE SILENCE?"
"Could you list exactly what these 'hundreds of changes' are?"
SOME of these changes can be found listed in the following
For the probable source for these changes, see:
I am currently working on an uptodate article that will
give all the significant details similar to the article I
wrote on "Reprint of A Modern Panarion by the Theosophy Company"
which can be read at:
If one looks at the publisher's preface to the Thesophy
Company's facsimile reprint of the SD, one can find certain
VALID criticisms of various questioned editions of the SD.
These criticisms are right on the mark ....
and can ALSO be applied to the Theosophy Co.'s edition of the
I rephrase the criticisms to apply to the TC edition of the VOICE:
The TC edition "is marred" by many hundreds of "alterations", "some
of them trivial, some actual mutilations of the original text."
The TC edition has "gratuitous 'corrections' of the author's
The "exact authenticity" of the TC edition "cannot be determined
without laborious comparison with the original" 1889 edition.
The publisher's preface to the Theosophy Company's edition of the SD
has this notable statement:
"With the present printing of THE SECRET DOCTRINE, The Theosophy
Company continues its function of providing students and inquirers
with unaltered editions of the original literature of the
Theosophical Movement. . . . this edition is a perfect facsimile of
the original edition and can be relied upon as such."
In contrast, ....
with the printing of THE VOICE OF THE SILENCE, The Theosophy Company
did NOT continue its function of providing students and inquirers
with UNALTERED editions of the ORIGINAL literature. The TC edition
of the VOICE is NOT a perfect fasimile of the original 1889 edition
and CANNOT be relied upon as such.
Furthermore, this TC edition has been in print and sold for more
than 7 decades and during this time there has been no publisher's
note in said edition indicating that the text is edited, changed and
corrected. Therefore many students have assumed that the reprint is
an unaltered reproduction of HPB's original text.
When I first published the above findings years ago on Theos-Talk, I
had many ULT students writing to me and basically saying that I was
mistaken or even lying when I said there were any changes. They
insisted that the Theosophy Company would never publish an edited
and altered version of HPB's classic. I remember sending to a few
of them photocopies of HPB's original VOICE. One associate upon
receiving the photocopies wrote me that he was disillusioned with
the ULT for this and said he planned to drop his associateship in
the ULT. Another one wrote me when he received the photocopies and
told me he was cutting off all future communications with me.
Unfortunately, these unacknowledged changes in the VOICE cast
serious doubt on what Dallas wrote some years ago on Theos-Talk:
"In U.L.T. I don't have t[o] worry -- the originals are
available on a reliable basis. . . . "
Dallas also stated at the same time:
"Personally I would rather deal with H.P.Blavatsky's 'mistakes' than
with those created by others who have had the temerity to believe
they knew better than she did, and had the audacity to introduce
changes which she did not authorize. Strong language, but true if it
But for reasons I still cannot fathom Dallas still seems to prefer
the altered edition of the VOICE by the Theosophy Company and
continues to recommend this edition instead of, for example, the
facsimile of the 1889 edition published by Kessinger.
See the Kessinger edition at Amazon.com:
Finally, from the two statements to be found AT THE BOTTOM of the
it would appear that not only Judge made some of these changes, but
also G.R.S. Mead and Annie Besant!
As far as I know the only ULT associate that has dealt with this
issue in a straightforward and frank manner has been Wes Amerman:
Hope this helps.
[Back to Top]
Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application